So this is another Pinterest find, but I did change up the original recipe, just a smidge. Here's where I got the recipe/idea from: Portobello Pizza Bites
Ingredients:
**NOTE: I only made this for myself & had a side of avocado, tomato, mozzarella, evoo, & basil salad. By myself with nothing else, I could probably eat closer to two of these ;)**
**NOTE2: The list of ingredients is totally up to you & how much stuff you want on your pizza, so apologies for no exact measurements**
1 Large Portobello Mushroom Cap
Marinara Sauce (from the can & proud!)
Fresh Mozzarella Cheese (cubed)
Red Peppers
Turkey Pepperoni
Parmesan Cheese
What To Do:
- Set your oven to 400 degrees, while your oven preheats, start on your mushrooms.
- Take your mushroom & with a damp paper towel clean the top side of the mushroom. Be really gentle with it, don't run the mushroom under water as they tend to soak up liquid easily & will have a more rubbery texture if you do that.
- With a spoon scoop out the underside of the mushroom, be careful with this as well, the mushroom is "sensitive". Also scoop out/off the stem. Toss all that fun stuff & now you have the "bread" for your pizza.
- On a baking sheet lined with foil place your mushroom top side down. Bake for 7 minutes.
- Remove your mushroom from the oven. **Mine was a little sweaty so I drained the excess liquid & cleaned it up just a bit**
- While your creating your pizza, turn on your broiler
- Spread your marinara sauce, add your mozzarella & the remaining toppings.
- Once your broiler is ready, put your topped pizza back in the oven for 3-5 minutes, mine were in there for about 4 minutes, just wanted to get it melty.
- Enjoy!! This is definitely a "knife & fork" kind of pizza, the mushroom wasn't really crispy, so I think it may be hard to eat like a regular slice of pizza
Stuff I'd Do Differently Next Time:
Ingredients:
**NOTE: I only made this for myself & had a side of avocado, tomato, mozzarella, evoo, & basil salad. By myself with nothing else, I could probably eat closer to two of these ;)**
**NOTE2: The list of ingredients is totally up to you & how much stuff you want on your pizza, so apologies for no exact measurements**
1 Large Portobello Mushroom Cap
Marinara Sauce (from the can & proud!)
Fresh Mozzarella Cheese (cubed)
Red Peppers
Turkey Pepperoni
Parmesan Cheese
What To Do:
- Set your oven to 400 degrees, while your oven preheats, start on your mushrooms.
- Take your mushroom & with a damp paper towel clean the top side of the mushroom. Be really gentle with it, don't run the mushroom under water as they tend to soak up liquid easily & will have a more rubbery texture if you do that.
- With a spoon scoop out the underside of the mushroom, be careful with this as well, the mushroom is "sensitive". Also scoop out/off the stem. Toss all that fun stuff & now you have the "bread" for your pizza.
- On a baking sheet lined with foil place your mushroom top side down. Bake for 7 minutes.
- Remove your mushroom from the oven. **Mine was a little sweaty so I drained the excess liquid & cleaned it up just a bit**
- While your creating your pizza, turn on your broiler
- Spread your marinara sauce, add your mozzarella & the remaining toppings.
- Once your broiler is ready, put your topped pizza back in the oven for 3-5 minutes, mine were in there for about 4 minutes, just wanted to get it melty.
- Enjoy!! This is definitely a "knife & fork" kind of pizza, the mushroom wasn't really crispy, so I think it may be hard to eat like a regular slice of pizza
![]() |
| Finished product on the right, good stuff. |
I think I'd like to place the mushroom under the broiler for maybe a minute before adding the toppings, just to see if any "crisping" would happen & also maybe season the actual mushroom itself, not 100% sure with what, but this recipe was so easy that I think you can make it your own without really messing anything up. Also, I want to try these as tiny little appetizers by using the mini portobello mushroom caps, they'd be so fun & easy to make!
Oh the possibilities.....try 'em out, let me know what you think! Hope you enjoy!






















